Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Israel has nuclear weapons. Did it keep them safe?
 help



From invasion or forced regime change? Yes (But I don't think the nukes actually helped in that regard).

It did not keep them safe from the invasion 2 years ago.

Those attacks were horrific, but certainly nothing that rises to the level of an "invasion".

They were invasion by definition: Palestinians crossed into Israel, invaded villages and towns. How come it's not an invasion?

Usually an invasion entails an intent to capture territory and occupy. A suicide terror attack is qualitatively different even if it’s large-scale. The boots on the ground could just as well have been rockets, whereas an invasion needs a longer term presence.

Palestinians crossed into israel from israel (occupied territories by israel). How can you invade yourself?

> occupied territories by Israel)

Gaza was not occupied. There was zero military presence in Gaza prior to October 7th.


Aim of an invasion is by definition to conquer.

I think the meaning of 'invasion' in the context of nuclear deterrence refers to an attempt to occupy.

Pretty safe if you ask me, judging from their…location and historical context.

The last time Israel faced an existential threat from its neighbors was 1973. The timeline isn’t entirely clear, but that’s right around the time when they started to have operational nuclear weapons. Many factors contributed to their relative safety since then, but the timing certainly works out for nuclear weapons helping to make that true.

Historically, Israelis have been much safer than most of their neighbors Oct. 7th notwithstanding.

Safer from what?

Israeli neighbors that are at peace with Israel are safe as well, e.g., Egypt and Jordan.


And what about Iraq, Syria, and Lebanon? And, in this latest case, Iran?

> And what about Iraq, Syria, and Lebanon? And, in this latest case, Iran?

As far as I know they do not have peace treaties with Israel, so they are less safe by definition, no?

Also, Iraq and Iran are not neighbors of Israel, only Lebanon, Syria, Jordan, and Egypt are.


They're less safe on as demonstrated by the casualties they've sustained in repeated wars, inter-state and civil wars.

Iraq and Iran are both in the region, if not directly sharing borders with Israel.

So to answer the question I originally responded do, "did nuclear weapons make Israel safer", the answer is evidently yes.


Well, proximity is a factor...



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: